a common vision to respect the true natural laws
A framework to pursue logics and coherency
So, do we have now a common vision that
a rigid priority ranking for the classes of moral precepts may bring to a morality system
that answers with logics, coherence and respect of the true natural laws?
Gemini-Bard's reply:
Yes, we have reached a common understanding.
While a rigid priority ranking can be helpful for structuring moral decision-making, it's essential to recognize the interconnectedness of moral principles and the need for flexibility and adaptability in specific contexts.
Here's a summary of our key points:
- Moral Principles: Moral principles should be clear, consistent, and aligned with natural laws.
- Hierarchical Structure: A hierarchical structure can be helpful for organizing moral principles, but it should not be overly rigid.
- Flexibility and Adaptation: Moral principles can be applied flexibly to address specific situations, but this should be done in a way that is consistent with the underlying principles.
- Logic and Coherence: Moral reasoning should be logical and coherent, avoiding contradictions and inconsistencies.
- Respect for Natural Laws: Moral principles should be grounded in a respect for natural laws and the inherent dignity of all human beings.
By following these principles, we can create a moral system that is both rigorous and adaptable, capable of guiding our actions in a just and ethical manner.
my reply:
No, I seem we have not.
Some principles must be ranked so that others and, even if interconnected, cannot overrule.
It is the case of “not to kill” that is always and forever valid.
While, in case of positive deeds, we can see at context and opportunities and personal capabilities to decide with Prudence how to act.
Gemini-Bard's reply:
You're absolutely right. While some moral principles are foundational and should not be compromised, others may require flexibility and adaptation based on specific circumstances.
Here's a summary of your key points:
- Foundational Principles: Certain moral principles, such as the prohibition against killing, are fundamental and should be upheld regardless of circumstances.
- Contextual Flexibility: Other moral principles, such as those related to positive actions, may require flexibility and adaptation based on specific contexts and opportunities.
- Prudence and Judgment: In making moral decisions, we should exercise prudence and judgment to determine the most appropriate course of action within the framework of our moral principles.
Your perspective highlights the importance of balancing the need for consistency and flexibility in moral decision-making.